In Crikey this week, Bernard Keane made the point that Australia accepts a disproportionately small number of asylum-seekers given our population size. So, where exactly do we rank in the world in terms of generosity towards displaced persons? The United Nations Refugee Agency provides a wide range of statistics about refugees and asylum-seekers. The latest monthly data gives the number of asylum-seeker applications by country for 2009 up to and including August. The chart below shows a ranking of the 44 countries who reported accepting asylum-seekers over this period. Australia finds itself well down the list in 20th place. Mind you, the United States ranks a few spots behind us and, despite having a better reputation when it comes to taking refugees, New Zealand is even further behind. Malta is by far the most welcoming country for refugees.
So, how many more asylum-seekers should we be taking to be accepting our fair share? Keane approaches the question by considering the relative size of our population to the population of the world. However, there are many countries that are a source of refugees that could not realistically accept asylum-seekers. So, instead the baseline should be an equal share of asylum-seekers based on the relative size of a country’s population to the combined population of the 44 countries who have been taking asylum-seekers (a total of 1.14 billion).
The magic number, shown as a grey line in the chart, is 197 asylum-seekers per million population. This means that Australia’s fair share for 2009 to August should be 4,197 rather than the 3,666 we have taken so far. So, we could easily accept the 255 Sri Lankan boat people currently seeking asylum in Australia, and still have room for more. Mind you, Australia only just falls below the average rate, ranking just behind Germany which takes in slightly more asylum-seekers than average.
For anyone wishing to explore this data further, I have uploaded it to Swivel. It also includes data on asylum-seeker intake per billion US dollars of Gross Domestic Product (GDP). Population and GDP data is taken from the CIA World Fact Book. Here is a chart of rankings by GDP.
UPDATE: New and easier to read charts have now been posted here: A better view of the asylum-seeker league tables.
Possibly Related Posts (automatically generated):
- A better view of the asylum-seeker league tables (19 October 2009)
- Vaccination of the Nation (5 July 2021)
- Does Switzerland have the world’s best universities? (13 October 2009)
- Deceptive Charts #2 (20 November 2009)